Ring Wise
One in Five Women Dislike Their Engagement Rings and 49.3% Will Never Tell Their Partners

Does She Actually Like the Ring?
You've saved for months. You know more about diamond clarity than you ever thought you would, you've sat through countless sales pitches, and you've finally found the perfect ring. You get down on one knee, she cries, and she says yes. It's everything you hoped it would be.
But what if she spends the next forty years wearing a ring she secretly wishes looked different?
It sounds like a nightmare scenario, but it's more common than you might think.
How Many Women Dislike Their Engagement Rings?
In 2016, British jeweller Lewis Malka made headlines when his research found that 20% of women disliked their engagement rings. The finding was widely reported under an even more dramatic headline: one in five women hate their engagement rings. The research went on to inspire Malka's book, The Engagement Ring, a guide intended to help people navigate one of the most meaningful jewellery purchases they'll ever make.
Nearly a decade later, another survey uncovered something just as surprising. In 2025, jewellery retailer Modern Gents surveyed 1,000 women who had been engaged. Among those who were unhappy with their rings, 49.3% had never told their partners how they really felt.
It's not difficult to understand why. Imagine telling someone who has just made one of the biggest romantic gestures of his life that you don't particularly like the ring he chose. He put thought, money, and effort into finding something he believed you'd love. Admitting otherwise could feel ungrateful, even if your feelings are perfectly reasonable. So you smile, say thank you, and convince yourself it doesn't matter.
But should anyone have to spend the rest of their life wearing something they don't like just to protect their partner's feelings?
What About Women Who Want to Be Surprised?
The obvious solution might seem to be involving women in choosing their engagement rings. After all, they're the ones who will be wearing them. But that overlooks something important: some women genuinely want the ring to be a surprise.
They don't want to visit jewellery stores, compare diamond specifications, or approve a final design. They want their partner to choose something for them, and they want that moment of opening the box and seeing it for the first time.
According to a 2017 Robbins Brothers survey reported by National Jeweler, 20% of female respondents believed their partners should know their style well enough to choose an engagement ring independently.
For these women, the fact that their partner chose the ring is part of what makes it special. It's a reflection of how well he knows them, how closely he's paid attention, and the thought he's put into finding something they'll love. There's something romantic about receiving a ring that your partner picked out entirely on his own, especially when it turns out to be exactly what you would have chosen for yourself.
But there's a difference between wanting to be surprised and wanting your partner to take a wild guess. She might want nothing to do with the shopping process, but still expect him to know that she prefers yellow gold, loves oval diamonds, and has never worn anything remotely resembling a halo setting. She wants the excitement of not knowing what he'll choose, but she also wants to feel like he chose it with her in mind. Those two things don't have to be mutually exclusive.
The Most Expensive Ring Isn't Always the Right One
There's a tendency to assume that a bigger diamond or a more expensive ring will naturally make someone happier. But the research suggests otherwise. In the same 2025 Modern Gents survey, nearly 72% of women said the thought and effort behind their engagement ring mattered more than its price or size.
A two-carat diamond might sound impressive, but it could be completely wrong for someone who prefers delicate, understated jewellery. An elaborate setting might look beautiful in a display case but feel out of place on someone who rarely wears accessories. Then there's lifestyle to consider. A ring with a high-profile setting might be stunning, but how practical is it for someone who works with their hands all day?
These are details that can easily get lost when shopping becomes a competition to find the biggest diamond or the most impressive design within a budget. It's understandable, especially when there's so much emphasis placed on diamond size, quality, and price. But those factors don't necessarily tell you whether the person receiving the ring will actually enjoy wearing it.
A ring can be beautiful, expensive, and thoughtfully chosen, and still not be right for the person receiving it. That's what makes engagement ring shopping so tricky. You're not just looking for a beautiful ring. You're looking for one that feels like her.
Maybe We're Asking the Wrong Question
Most conversations about engagement rings eventually come down to the same debate: should women choose their own rings, or should their partners choose for them? But perhaps we're overlooking a more important question. What would she actually prefer?
Would she enjoy being involved in the selection process, or would that take away something she was looking forward to? Would she love knowing her partner chose the ring himself, or would she rather have some say in something she'll wear every day? Has she already mentioned what she likes, pointed out rings on social media, or admired a friend's engagement ring? And if her partner isn't sure what she'd like, how can he learn more about her preferences without necessarily spoiling the surprise?
These questions might seem small, but they speak to something much bigger about relationships. We often approach romantic gestures by imagining what we would find meaningful. We put effort into creating the perfect moment, buying the perfect gift, or planning the perfect surprise, without always stopping to consider whether our partner would want the same thing.
Someone might spend months researching diamonds, visiting jewellers, and saving for an expensive ring, only to overlook the fact that their partner has always preferred simple jewellery. The effort is genuine, and the intentions are good, but the result might still miss the mark.
Being thoughtful isn't just about how much time, money, or effort you put into something. It's also about how well you understand the person you're doing it for.
There's No One Right Way to Choose an Engagement Ring
The research tells us that engagement ring disappointment is real, and that some women would rather keep that disappointment to themselves than risk hurting someone they love. But it also highlights how differently people feel about the ring-shopping process itself.
Some women want to design their dream ring themselves. Others are happy to share a few preferences and leave the final decision to their partner. And some want the entire experience to be a surprise. None of these approaches is inherently more romantic than another, and there's no reason to assume that what works for one couple will work for everyone.
Shopping for a ring together doesn't make a proposal any less meaningful, just as choosing a ring independently doesn't mean someone is being careless or inconsiderate. Both approaches can be equally thoughtful when they reflect what the people involved actually want.
Ultimately, the best way to choose an engagement ring is the way that makes sense for your relationship. Maybe that means shopping together, asking a few questions, or paying close enough attention to know what she'd love without ever having to ask. There's no single right answer, because no two relationships are exactly alike.
The important thing is knowing your partner well enough to understand what would make her happy. After all, if you're about to ask someone to spend the rest of her life with you, understanding what matters to her is a pretty good place to start.